GameFly - Game Rental Reviews - 888 Post-Delivery Reviews - 9.4/10

KingTaray

Jun 18, 2026

Awesome

sj

Jun 18, 2026

n//

Geralt

Jun 18, 2026

Was pretty smooth. Had to refresh for my account to load. But maybe was my connection mostly. It kept trying to off 30 day trial when I’m not eligible.

Soul12eaper

Jun 18, 2026

Purchase a gane i rented. I have purchased many games i have rented through GF because I feel the pricing is a great bargain.

Reescree

Jun 18, 2026

Pretty good, but as long as I have been a member I would expect even more discounts. Like a loyalty discount or something.

Elecwarrior

Jun 18, 2026

Good, less expensive option buying former rental copies.

GEARMan

Jun 18, 2026

The budget game option is great for those who still have a backlog of games to play but still want to to try other games. Especially for Nintendo games that rarely ever go down in price.

JC

Jun 18, 2026

I've always had great experiences purchasing through GameFly and for game rentals. The order tracking is helpful and my orders always arrive on time.

Mike

Jun 18, 2026

I love ordering from gamefly because they usually have great deals for members

BizzyBanks

Jun 17, 2026

the price of keeping a good game was not bad at all

Stall

Jun 17, 2026

Decent price but would have been better if it was free shipping.

Jay

Jun 17, 2026

So far I have had a very good expirence and have no complaints although the price might have been a bit much compared to what was listed.

Super13

Jun 17, 2026

I usually always like that you get the cases with the games. As a collector, I like getting everything in perfect shape. One game, the case came cracked, but game was good.

Online Shopper

Jun 17, 2026

No problem.

Bizzle

Jun 17, 2026

I wish there were more collectibles, but overall... I love GameFly

Thetallone

Jun 17, 2026

It has been good so far

Brad

Jun 17, 2026

Great deal on used game and each game came in near brand new condition. Delivery was quicker than I anticipated too

Nick K

Jun 17, 2026

Ordered game arrived on time and in perfect condition.

TWMIV

Jun 16, 2026

I have been using the movie rental service for over a year now and recently purchased a switch 2. In looking for some deals on games, I found that the catalog has a high degree of JRPG's or similar type titles. While those do not appeal to me, it is likely what is being rented/requested in volume. There are some locations in the app which throw up a web based login captured in the app, this is a bit annoying for two reasons. 1, I am already logged in. 2, the app doesn't appear to be registered at the system level (android) correctly for my password manager to identify it (1password). I believe this may be due to an app ID or app name or something similar.

Hunter

Jun 16, 2026

My favorite part about gamefly, as a collector is how im always going to get the game and case in fabulous condition. Normally cheaper than elsewhere with cheap shipping.

Drew

Jun 16, 2026

Easy !

Joseph81

Jun 16, 2026

So what I wanted, saw it was a good price, saw that the shipping wasn't terrible and I ordered it. It arrived and perfect condition and with the sticker that I appreciated however the shipping could have been quicker not entirely sure it's gameflys fault though

FangBanger91

Jun 16, 2026

Love the discount and checkout was easy. Wish things shipped a bit faster but overall I'm satisfied with my experience so far.

Marc

Jun 16, 2026

Air has been great. I like receiving the $10 off coupons for preorders

Dee

Jun 16, 2026

Everything's good

Kell

Jun 16, 2026

Very good

Tim

Jun 16, 2026

Good deals, easy checkout experience, and reasonable shipping costs.

Steen

Jun 16, 2026

Gamefly is excellent as always! though I do wish I had a coupon; the ones I had didn't apply to purchase. But the price of game is still good.

Heero

Jun 16, 2026

It was fine. Hard to get the item, kept on going in and out of stock. Price was 5 dollars too high from competition.

Jor

Jun 16, 2026

I enjoy the fact that I can get games at a discount I don't see anywhere else.

Zagspixy

Jun 15, 2026

It was a straightforward purchase, my coupons automatically applied during checkout, very happy with the ease of purchasing my rented game.

Brownbear

Jun 15, 2026

It was fine thank you

Riggo

Jun 15, 2026

It was fast and easy

DK

Jun 15, 2026

Renting games through Gamefly gives you better value than buying a brand new game at face value ($70), you get to play the whole game on your own time and busy schedule and then when you are tired of it or beat it just pop it back in the pre-labeled envelope they send you and put it in your mailbox (make sure to put up the little red flag for the mailman) and done! Onto the next game on your queue. One little wish: it would be great if you could have Gamefly "anticipate" your next game being sent out to you without the gap of rental to mailbox to being acknowledged as shipped by the postal service. In order to reduce that lag time till the next game. I get it though, its kind of like the honor system otherwise and they need to prove you are returning the current game. My plan is to burn through as many games as I can and get caught up on my backlog so this does slow me down some. Also- it would be great if there was a perspective on older games to rent that have come and gone by, a lot of upcoming games are featured which is great, but you actually have to dig around to find them. I do have to say they have heft discounts on used games that crushes the competition, I just caught Metal Gear Solid Delta for $19 which is insane! Comparison: Best Buy ($57), Gamestop ($39), Walmart ($37) or Amazon ($37).

brobromydude666

Jun 15, 2026

Love y'all

Rhyslanter

Jun 15, 2026

Love you guys. love every single ascpect of this company and business model. Games come in quick and on time no scratches or dents. will definetly continue to use this service its easy to use.

Matty

Jun 15, 2026

Good price easy service and cheap prices

Ssk

Jun 15, 2026

i love game fly and have had a positive experience except for one time when my order never areived though i was refunded so it is all good

Daniel G

Jun 14, 2026

Very straightforward and easy to use.

Superpig

Jun 14, 2026

Good experience

Gnomepants

Jun 14, 2026

Quick, easy checkout and plenty of discounts

Scott G

Jun 14, 2026

I have been a member seem like for ever and I have always been satisfied with gamefly

CarlM

Jun 14, 2026

Easy and efficient zero hassle

Pokey904

Jun 14, 2026

More overall interaction was good. Everything was simple to find it and it described everything perfect.

Blindfirejp

Jun 13, 2026

So far it's been great, a little sad the service costs so much when digital is instant, but these used sales do keep bringing me back.

Parker

Jun 13, 2026

It was amazing and quick

Jesse

Jun 13, 2026

Been great experience so far recommend 100 percent

Adri

Jun 13, 2026

The subscription said that members get free shipping but I didn’t get free shipping. I am a member of the free trial.

Mimi

Jun 13, 2026

Very simple and easy to use

Slim - Ace

Jun 13, 2026

Honestly this being my first time on Gamefly website I was thoroughly impressed how easily I was able to find the exact purchase at a price lower than all the competition. Navigating the website was incredibly easy and the process was straightforward with no issues. In closing I found my number #1 gaming website all in the matter of minutes, so I highly recommend Gamefly and now I understand why GameStop and other gaming stores are struggling and I'm not mad at it! 10/10!