Skip to main content

Horse Saddle Shop Customer Reviews

Horse Saddle Shop holds a 9.6/10 overall rating and 161 verified post-delivery reviews on Bizrate.

Horse Saddle Shop logo
Certified
Most Current Certification:
Nov 19, 2026
HorseSaddleShop.com includes saddle experts, customer service and products that customer will love. They take great efforts to work efficiently to reduce prices and pass the savings on to customers.

Horse Saddle Shop Rating

Customer Certified
Certified

Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

Circle of Excellence
Circle of Excellence - Horse Saddle Shop

2022 Winner Circle of Excellence

2 years

Trust & Authority

No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!

Learn more about reviews
Post-Delivery Feedback - 161 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.6out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.6out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.7out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

93%88%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

5%8%
Negative rating icon

Negative

2%4%

On-Time Delivery

Satisfaction with order arrival relative to expected order receipt date

9.8 out of 10

Order Tracking

Satisfaction with the ability to track the order

9.9 out of 10

Product Met Expectations

Correct product was delivered, is of the expected quality, and works as described/depicted

9.7 out of 10

Customer Support

Satisfaction with assisted or self-service help

9.6 out of 10

Product Availability

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.7 out of 10

Returns Process

Satisfaction with the returns process

9 out of 10

Site Experience Feedback - 605 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.5out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.5out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.5out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

85%80%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

12%16%
Negative rating icon

Negative

3%4%

Ease of Finding What You Are Looking For

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.5 out of 10

Design of Site

Satisfaction with the look and design of the site

9.3 out of 10

Satisfaction With Checkout

Satisfaction with the checkout process

9.4 out of 10

Product Selection

Satisfaction with the breadth of products available on the site

9.6 out of 10

Clarity of Product Information

How clear and understandable was the product information

9.4 out of 10

Charges Stated Clearly

Total purchase amount (including shipping, handling and discounts) displayed before order submission

9.2 out of 10

Prices Relative to Other Online Retailers

Comparison of prices relative to other websites selling similar products

9 out of 10

Shipping Charges

Satisfaction with shipping charges

8.9 out of 10

Variety of Shipping Options

Desired shipping options were available

9.4 out of 10

Recent Reviews for Horse Saddle Shop

Showing 1 - 50 of 766

  • Lady Di

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    Very easy to navigate and order.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Ciera

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    Easy and quick to identify what I needed.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    I have not received my saddle pad yet

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 1
    • On Time Delivery: N/A
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Sis

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    Great value and quality and easy checkout

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Sheila

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    It was fine

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Joe

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    You had what I needed ,thank you

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Dana

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 18, 2026

    seems to have great prices

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Jessica

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    Check out was easy

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Mk

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    Good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Lindy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    It was good

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Return satisfied customer 777

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Navigating the site is simple and clear. I really appreciate that all saddle measurements are clearly posted. It's important that each saddle fits both horse and rider.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • CP

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 15, 2026

    Would like western saddle angles listed

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Oliver

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    Great saddle return policy.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Su

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    it was ok ive had ut be bettervin the past

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Pam

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    easy to navigate, multiply options for what I was looking for. Quality products to choose from. Prices comparable to other companies.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Judge

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    For some reason wouldn’t accept PayPal. Rest of it was good

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • SteveG54

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Website was easy to navigate and the checkout process was quick and easy.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Julie

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Very easy to navagate

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Bsr

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    everything was just like it was supposed to be received my order within 3 days of ordering i couldnt be more pleased

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • rachael

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    the chat didnt work so I just ordered the saddle fitting tool

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Sarah

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    Excellent

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Andrea

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    No pictures of what is in the matching package, so no clue what I'm actually getting.

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 5
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 3
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Joe

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    Very Friendly.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • L3

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I have nothing to complain about

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Ray

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I had a great experience calling to talk with Horse Saddle Shop about a used saddle I wanted to purchase. They were very helpful and super informative about the saddle I was calling about. I have been looking for months for the perfect saddle that would not break the bank!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Barnmedic

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I purchased the saddle fitting tool and am actively working on purchasing saddles for our 2 hard to fit horses. I'm extremely impressed with the tool, and especially with knowledge and patience of the support team. I have already recommended the Horse Saddle Shop to 2 friends who are also looking for saddles.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Reese B

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    very easy to follow and purchase

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Hill Billy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Great customer service and communication on the specialized bridals I needed to order.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    free shipping should be less spent. I spent over 100 and didnt get to free shipping

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Hillyeahfarms

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    Cheapest price on the web for Justin Boots

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Dee

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    wanted new stirrups. called the store for help to match the saddle i just purchased the week before. within 5 minutes i had the info i needed and i placed my order. I love this store

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Cowboy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    Yes , seems like a good place to shop

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    • On Time Delivery: 9
    • Customer Support: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Roo’s mom

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    I have been struggling with saddle fit for nearly a year, I located Saddle Shop online and became excited about looking for a saddle again. My gelding’s health mental and physical are important to me. After receiving the tool I measured him and then reached out to Patrick with measurements. I’m looking forward to seeing recommendations. I felt listened to especially about the sadness of having to give up my current saddle because I am as in love with it as I am my horse. Patrick understood my fondness of the detail of my saddle so I’m excited to see the options offered.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • AF

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    I found the selection great and the check out easy-was not a lot of options for shipping to Canada so I took the only one offered, Thanks Andrew.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Horse Girl

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    Ordering was very simple. I have purchased Saddle Pad and bridles from this shop. It's always great customer service.

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Nol

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Purchasing experience was great however the left boot is creating a blister on my left foot after wearing the boots one time. This has never happened before with other Tony Lamas which leads me to believe boots may have a defect. I plan on taking the boots to a boot repair shop this weekend.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Melissa

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Overall, my experience was good. The number of saddles to choose from, new and used, was great. I liked being able to use the live chat to upload pictures and get advice. However, I have 3 complaints. The first being that I originally purchased a saddle and then after about 2 days I contacted customer support to see why I hadn't received a tracking number. I then got a notification about my refund and then saw the email saying the saddle I paid for was actually sold 2 days before I purchased it and it just hadn't been "scanned out". I was very disappointed and back to square one. Second, I had submitted the form giving all the details needed for someone to give expert advice on what saddles might work well for me and my horse. Even after messaging and asking when I would hear back, I never received a response for saddle recommendations. So after waiting for over a month, I decided to just use the live chat and figure it out. Lastly, when I received the box with the saddle, the box was pretty beat up and inside was the receipt of someone else's purchase. With their name and address and all their purchase information on it. I'm happy so far with the saddle I bought but the experience definitely could've been better.

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Boden

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Great customer service they went over and above to make sure everything was perfect

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • SaltedDaisy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    Good website, easy to use

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Bonnie

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    Great shop with great prices!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tex

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    It worked fine.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Happy horse owner

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    was easyvro find and order

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Karen S

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    I ordered gifts for grand kids. The selection was good and the price was the best I found. The product arrived in a timely manner and was packaged well. I will use Horse Saddle Shop in the future.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Katrina

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    I love your prices and the tack selection is amazing. I will continue to shop here! I will also tell my friends about your store. I also love the easy checkout.

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Brandon R

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    everything is good so far just made my order which went well just waiting on the product to arrive

    • Overall Rating: 5
    • Would Shop Here Again: 6
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 6
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tonya

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    It was super easy. I look forward to checking my saddle size and ordering a new saddle soon.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Cowboy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    Good

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Dee

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    Easy to use

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Cat

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    Very easy website to work with.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Peggy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    i have purchased a few items from horse saddle shop and i have never been dissatisfyed in the products or servive!!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »