GemSelect Reviews - 30 Post-Delivery Reviews - 9.7/10

Nik

Jun 11, 2026

It was great

Online Shopper

Jun 8, 2026

I will not know how to rate until I receive the product.

Varun

Jun 5, 2026

Very pleasant

Ron T

Jun 2, 2026

Always get a nice gemstone. Just like the picture. Never disappointed

Mich

Jun 2, 2026

Easy, quick.

Chip

May 31, 2026

Had to get here via the Facebook page. Googling direct brought up an error message.

Gem

May 28, 2026

Ok

Liz

May 25, 2026

Easy to use. Many options to find the right gemstone

My real name Dean or Wandering about

May 24, 2026

My current project is something BLUE . Opal earrings with matching tennis bracelet for her wedding. The opals and sixty two sapphires VVS & VS are AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL. The private jewelers were impressed by the clarity and inclusion free of the sapphires . I want to say thank you for the High quality sapphires that I purchased for my daughter’s wedding.

Online Shopper

May 22, 2026

Very clear photos and specifications helped me narrow down the gem I wanted.

Amman

May 21, 2026

It’s a pretty good and simple way to find gems that you’re looking for amazing selection

Alexis

May 21, 2026

Recomendado Totalmente Los Productos Se Entregaron A Tiempo

Online Shopper

May 21, 2026

Very helpful and accommodating in all aspects of selecting and meeting what I was looking for.Very forthright and honest people to deal with.

rahul

May 19, 2026

NA

Matthew K.

May 17, 2026

Absolutely love Gem Select. I always know the quality and accuracy of information and photos are top notch. Highly recommend!

Online Shopper

May 15, 2026

It was great experience

Online Shopper

May 12, 2026

Good

Matthew K.

May 11, 2026

Was really easy and straightforward! Design could look a little less elementary/be more professional. I think that’d take your site from great to perfect!

Big Ricky

May 10, 2026

Site worked well and helped me find a rock that matched what I was looking for. Well within budget and I trust it will show up, so that's definitely positive. Not much else to it. Satisfied.

Varun

May 9, 2026

Good, hope gem quality is good and genuine

zeak

May 9, 2026

easy interface for a pricless buy

Skot

May 5, 2026

Found a rock that met my need. Bought it!

Bawb

May 3, 2026

Fast snd easy to find what I was looking for

Kelly

May 3, 2026

I found the filter options excellent. Yours was the third site I visited (asked chat got for reputable online sellers of loose gems) and the first I purchased from as I was able to easily find what I was looking for.

CLTCJH

May 2, 2026

I liked the selection of gems, and price. I did not like your PayPal process. I already have a PP account and you want me to sign up for another.

ceil

May 2, 2026

Very good

James

May 2, 2026

I loved the selection of gemstones you have a to z

Mattick

May 1, 2026

I had a very easy time navigating the web page and using filters to find what I was looking for. The varied selection was nice to see and pricing is clear and fair.

Tree Dog

Apr 30, 2026

I was able to find what I've been looking for.

na

Apr 29, 2026

It was fine

wandering

Apr 27, 2026

no teal sapphire

dave

Apr 18, 2026

good navigation and simple interface.

Online Shopper

Apr 17, 2026

N/A

Spinellope

Apr 15, 2026

Great! Affordable

meyeusername

Apr 14, 2026

I bought a nummite stone, but learned it may not in fact be real nummite. There are no nummite deposits in India, the mainly come from Greenland so I'm curious what I may have actually bought. My research shows there are other stones that people sometimes sell as nummite. I'm hoping I'm wrong, but it's likely this stone is being sold under the wrong name. It is more likely Arfvedsonite or Astrophyllite. I do appreciate how quickly it arrived and the care taken in packing and sending it.

SR

Apr 10, 2026

overall great

Online Shopper

Apr 9, 2026

The whole experience was just great! Satisfied with all aspects!

Online Shopper

Apr 8, 2026

Very informative and easy to navigate online presence. Number of items avaiable when making selection would be helpful.

Lex

Apr 7, 2026

I loved it! Extensive inventory, great prices, I definitely will be buying from here again!

ToRa.62

Apr 7, 2026

Web site is very simple to navigate Selection is terrific

PickyShopper

Apr 7, 2026

This is the first time I have used this site. I was dissatisfied with the quality of gems and supplies elsewhere and decided to try GemSelect. They are awesome! I was thrilled to see the variety and the great web performance. There was the ability to search for information as well as gems. Things like the clarity rating system and caret weight of the gems. I have always loved making things and I have just started to make jewelry as a business. However I have never made a ring before and have always wanted to. On GemSelect I was able to find good quality gems to use in my creations. I am so glad the website is so easy to use. Thank you GemSelect.

ToRa62

Apr 4, 2026

Good selection prices are reasonable!

ToRa.62

Apr 3, 2026

Enjoy viewing the selections. Excellent product

Crafty Seabee

Mar 30, 2026

Easy process.

Dessa

Mar 29, 2026

Easy and functional

Guero

Mar 29, 2026

The website was easy to use and informative of the selection of stones it has. I quickly found the right stone for me.

Elansary

Mar 25, 2026

Very good place to buy gemstones

JC

Mar 23, 2026

They have literally everything on this website! The prices are also pretty good, I was able to find plenty of nice stones that I could afford!

Lkcisneros

Mar 23, 2026

GemSelect is always my first choice for purchasing gemstones. The fact that the gems are always exactly as described and pictured on the website has earned my trust many times over. Even when I don't buy, I still love browsing all the beautiful stones. My new favorites are the bright green Tsavorites!

Online Shopper

Mar 22, 2026

I purchased 4 Brazilian amethysts to make earrings for my granddaughters and I’ve referred to your site many times to others