Skip to main content

Brilliant Earth Customer Reviews

Brilliant Earth holds a 9/10 overall rating and 558 verified post-delivery reviews on Bizrate.

Brilliant Earth logo
Certified
Most Current Certification:
Nov 17, 2026
Brilliant Earth is an American company that sells jewelry featuring diamonds and other gemstones that are asserted to be ethically sourced. The company was established in August 2005 by Beth Gerstein and Eric Grossberg, and is headquartered in San Francisco, California.

Brilliant Earth Rating

Customer Certified
Certified

Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

Circle of Excellence
Circle of Excellence - Brilliant Earth

2020 Winner Circle of Excellence

4 years

Trust & Authority

No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!

Learn more about reviews
Post-Delivery Feedback - 558 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

8.7out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.2out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

78%85%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

13%9%
Negative rating icon

Negative

9%6%

On-Time Delivery

Satisfaction with order arrival relative to expected order receipt date

9.3 out of 10

Order Tracking

Satisfaction with the ability to track the order

9.1 out of 10

Product Met Expectations

Correct product was delivered, is of the expected quality, and works as described/depicted

8.8 out of 10

Customer Support

Satisfaction with assisted or self-service help

8.7 out of 10

Product Availability

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.6 out of 10

Returns Process

Satisfaction with the returns process

4.8 out of 10

Site Experience Feedback - 1,245 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.5out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.3out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.5out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

89%91%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

8%7%
Negative rating icon

Negative

3%2%

Ease of Finding What You Are Looking For

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.5 out of 10

Design of Site

Satisfaction with the look and design of the site

9.5 out of 10

Satisfaction With Checkout

Satisfaction with the checkout process

9.6 out of 10

Product Selection

Satisfaction with the breadth of products available on the site

9.4 out of 10

Clarity of Product Information

How clear and understandable was the product information

9.4 out of 10

Charges Stated Clearly

Total purchase amount (including shipping, handling and discounts) displayed before order submission

9.6 out of 10

Prices Relative to Other Online Retailers

Comparison of prices relative to other websites selling similar products

8.9 out of 10

Shipping Charges

Satisfaction with shipping charges

9.4 out of 10

Variety of Shipping Options

Desired shipping options were available

9.3 out of 10

Recent Reviews for Brilliant Earth

Showing 1 - 50 of 1,803

  • Alec

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Everything was great. Super simple and easy. I also bought my wife’s engagement ring and our wedding bands from brilliant earth

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • MA

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Easy to use. Already knew what I wanted

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • B

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 15, 2026

    Great experience! Have been looking for awhile and finally made the purchase

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • JD

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    Order came within a week and the rings are beautiful but the carbon on my wedding band had a gash in it. They're giving me an exchange but support didn't do much to make it right, I'm going to be stuck without a ring for weeks now because of their lack of quality control

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    well so far as a company Brillant Earth looks fantastic I did want more but the promos are a bit too pricy for me I was considering dropping 1k but after reviewing things it made more sense to ge tthis to get a feel for the company everythign looks gorgeous the prices are adequate emails are a bit too on the nose but i understand the market for these you gotta capitalize on your consumers

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Jrez

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Everything was simple to use, I had no issues

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Maggie

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    As described.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Kevin

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Absolutely wonderful. From the 360 view of the ring to the variety of jewelry, all the way to the check out and financing process. Everything just excellent.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tob

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Brilliant earth did a good job with making this purchase a very easy process

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Mads

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    This is my second time purchasing something from brilliant earth, and I will definitely get another purchase.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Katie

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Brilliant Earth is an excellent company, their site is easy to navigate. Their products are beautiful and high quality

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Carlos

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    All good, prices high

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Amy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    I was replacing my wedding ring due to a health issue that happened years ago, and this has been a very pleasant experience with a high quality ring.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • gr8ful69

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    Excellent Website and services so far

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • G Munny

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    Overall, great website. Very pretty and visually appealing. Also very easy to use. Well done all around. Only improvement I would appreciate, is that since this is a follow up from a showroom visit, is confirmation the sales person who helped us received credit for the sale. Otherwise, well done. And hope there's other ways to get discounts when purchasing outside Wire Transfers.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    I bought a ring and it was crocket shaped and I just bought a new one

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Justin

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    Process was very smooth! Allowed me to look at multiple styles and allowed me to make alterations to help find me the perfect ring. The prices seemed very reasonable!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Oscar

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    oscar.lopez001@icloud.com

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Luke

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    Had no issues with ordering from the website. Looking forward to receiving the product.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    GREAT PURCHASE. I BOUGHT MY WIFES WEDDING RING 9 YEARS AGO THROUGH BRILLIANT EARTH AND PLAN TO USE THEM FOR FUTURE PURCHASES. COMPLETELY SATISFIED CUTOMER

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Timeless Brilliance

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    Outstanding

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Borja

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    It was great. Very easy to go through the process

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Frank

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Interaction was fine, smooth and no issues

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • NA

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Awesome

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Ceebee

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I contacted for resizing and was given appropriate direction in terms of what to do.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    • On Time Delivery: 7
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Wedding Band

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I bought a rose gold 1/4 carat wedding band. The product itself was stunning and it came a couple days early.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • MTX

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Good- many options to choose from with very clear photos of item

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Everything is always great with brilliant earth

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Mosley

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    Overall interactions have been very good and given me positive feedback and the humanity on the other side of the in store visits and phone calls has been refreshing. HATE AI or automated phone services with a burning passion. I’ve already highly recommended Brilliant Earth to several people, one has purchased from yall.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Logan

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    I really apprecaite how friendly the site was to use, these are big decisions you are making and i did not feel like anything was hidden from me or missing.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    Good products, good website.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Nickname guy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    Good, I’ve built the ring a million times!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Hoosier

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    The experience was simple and easy

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 5
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Irishyankee

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    I really don't like giving so much personal info for a purchase

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Nurse Nick

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 7, 2026

    I purchased a beautiful wedding ring to go with the beautiful wedding band i bought from Brilliant Earth. Now the rings are a wedding set. I am a long time customer because of the beautiful and high quality jewelery .

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • AJ

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    Great

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    The communication directly from Brilliant Earth was excellent, including support staff, who followed uo to make sure i got my order that had been delayed. They were extremely accomodating and helpful to work with. The only drawback for me was the experience with Fedex. I would recommend working with a different delicery company in the future because they were not great to deal with.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 2
    • Customer Support: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Islander

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    I had a very positive experience both purchasing and now needing Customer support to return the item for an exchange to a larger size.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Emily

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    We had an absolutely wonderful experience with Brilliant Earth! Our engagement ring came out perfectly and arrived within the estimated timeframe. While the product itself exceeded our expectations, Tara Randall made the entire experience truly exceptional. Tara was warm, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful during our in-person visits. She guided us through options and helped us explore ideas without ever making us feel pressured. She made what could have been an overwhelming experience feel light, fun, and exciting. She was also incredibly patient with me, my fiancée, and my parents, who joined us for the shopping experience. Her care didn't stop after the initial purchase. Tara followed up throughout the process and continued helping us as we moved on to selecting our wedding bands. She even caught a potential engraving error and reached out immediately to make sure everything would be perfect. That level of attention to detail and genuine care speaks volumes about her. I absolutely LOVE Tara and cannot recommend her enough! I would happily recommend Brilliant Earth, but I would **HIGHLY recommend working with Tara Randall** if you have the opportunity. She made such a special milestone even more enjoyable, and we're so grateful we had her helping us along the way!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Mountaineer

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    Overall satisfied. One caveat...need by 12/23 and not guaranteed delivery by then

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Dehzh H.

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    I enjoyed the website but the check out was difficult to manage with the different check out options. Some did not work.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Alfredo Gomez

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    I love the quality of the items and costumer services that tou guys have. it would be great if you guys have mens gifts for purchase instead of only for women

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • El Patrón

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    great experience.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tommy81

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Easy to navigate and found what I was looking for easily and quickly. Ordered and waiting for the package to arrive!

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 6
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Lucy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    The website is excellent. it is easy to navegate. I did not have any issues

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Wes C

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    I bought my chain wore it for less than 4 hours took it off went to put back on and clasp broke. Literally 2nd time opening the clasp. Shipping was in time.

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: N/A
    • Customer Support: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • The Big Kahuna

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Everything about this site is quite amazing. I had no expectations coming to it, and then was blown away by absolutely all of the beautiful pieces and the ability to customize your ring to the exact specifications. I was happily entertained while customizing the ring I bought. However, the selection customization process is so vast that it did take a while. In fact that was very worth the time I spent. The ring I ended up getting is an engagement ring, and was priced very affordably.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Titan

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    N/A

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Disappointed

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    The product arrived and the first time I tried on the earrings one of them wouldn’t latch! It was broken from the get go. The customer service lady advised me to send them back “for review “. I felt frustrated by her response. So I’m going to DC and will return them in person. I want to make sure I get a full refund.

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Zach P.

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    I feel the filters and ease of the website was good.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
Brilliant Earth Customer Reviews | Verified Customer Reviews at Bizrate Surveys