Gotham Cigars Customer Reviews
Gotham Cigars holds a 9.4/10 overall rating and 621 verified post-delivery reviews on Bizrate.
Gotham Cigars Rating
Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

2023 Winner Circle of Excellence
3 years
No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!
Learn more about reviewsRecent Reviews for Gotham Cigars
Showing 1 - 50 of 3,038
Justin
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
The age verification section is terrible to get through having everything linked so that took the longest, if that process could be done more efficiently it would be perfect. Thank you for selling the Blackstone cherry cigars. I know how popular they can be. I do hope to be undated about my order, so far, I paid however no email was sent so maybe that could be done as soon as the purchase is done.
- Overall Rating: 4
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Bonzeebee
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
East access, easy to find product.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: 9
Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Fast and easy
- Overall Rating: 8
- Would Shop Here Again: 8
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Angie
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Everything was perfect
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
John18071
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Gotham Cigars has an excellent and well stocked inventory, their website is easy to use and negotiate, and the prices are very competitive. I highly recommend them.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: N/A
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Everything is always fresh never have an issue.
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
- On Time Delivery: N/A
- Customer Support: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad we were able to make things right with your first order. It means a lot to us that our customer service has earned your trust and keeps you coming back! We wish we were closer so you ...
Read full response »Ketsukoto
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Dope
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
Don't have one
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
I had all kinds of trouble trying get the product my husband needed. The shipping cost was horrible for a $1.55 prod cuct.
- Overall Rating: 5
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Ash
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Shouldn't be paying for shipping for something thats so light weight.
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 19, 2026
Love, returning customer.
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: 9
thai
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Needed cigars that aren't available where I live, so order them from you guys I tell all my friends to order from you to
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're happy to hear that you had a great experience and that everything went smoothly without any issues! We appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again! ~ Gotham Cigars
Nay
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Always available. great product!!
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: N/A
Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
use gotham for my cigars for years... my go-to
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
hth
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
the ordering format glitches are a weakness of the platform
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: 9
Puglover321
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Ordering is always easy and the products are always in stock.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: N/A
Mitch
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Gotham Cigars delivered my cigars faster than I expected and the packaging and cigars were in perfect condition. I am very satisfied with the delivery; I will definitely order from them again.
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear that your shopping experience was simple and hassle-free! Making things easy and convenient for our customers is always our goal, and we're happy we could deliver that for you...
Read full response »Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Prices selection are great. Shipping is expensive. Doesn’t make sense. If it’s in the United States again shopping and pricing are awesome shipping is the problem cost of doing business.
- Overall Rating: 5
- Would Shop Here Again: 6
- Likelihood To Recommend: 5
Big sky country
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
Quick and easy
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Aunt Fran
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
No more complicated than any other website. Plus, others sites were sold out of the Talons.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 7
none
Site Experience FeedbackNov 18, 2026
good
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Nicole
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
Okay experience wish things were cheaper. Easy to navigate
- Overall Rating: 7
- Would Shop Here Again: 8
- Likelihood To Recommend: 7
Nini
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
It's an easy site to use
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Alby
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
very good experience easy
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Jay
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
I like that Gotham has the cigars that I need in stock most of the time. The website is tricky in that it will verify your age then return to the checkout screen with the payment type erased or changed. I always have to put things in twice. Love the inventory though!
- Overall Rating: 8
- Would Shop Here Again: 8
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Luke
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
My subscription keeps ending unexpectedly.
- Overall Rating: 8
- Would Shop Here Again: 8
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
We had a great experience with our first order so we will order as long as we can! Thank you!
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
ERB
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
The website was easy to navigate and the items were clearly priced. The images of the items are high quality.
- Overall Rating: 8
- Would Shop Here Again: 8
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Jdub
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
Love the stock, ease of ordering.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Sherry
Site Experience FeedbackNov 17, 2026
great
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Blaze
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 17, 2026
I usually smoke Cheyenne Mentol. But they've been so hard to find for the last few weeks. So I got online and found your site and saw that The Derringer were made by Chyanne. o I got a carton sent to me. And I'm happy to report they taste as good as Cheyenne so I definitly will ordr more. Thank you
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: 7
Chad
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
It works well and has the product I want.
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: 7
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that our website works well for you and that you can find the products you're looking for! Making your shopping experience easy and convenient is always our goal, and we're g...
Read full response »Rondo
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
Website is great and easy to navigate
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you love our website and find it easy to navigate! We want every visit to be simple, smooth, and enjoyable, so your kind words truly mean a lot to us. We appreciate your...
Read full response »blue dog
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
You guys are good. I used to order from another place which is very good and would recommend, but they don't carry these cigars. I might be wrong but i think maybe these are better than smoking 3 or 4 fatboys a day.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you're pleased with Gotham Cigars and that we carry the cigars you couldn't find at your previous retailer! We truly appreciate you giving us a chance and sharing your e...
Read full response »T
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
Big
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts with us! Thank you for choosing us and we look forward to serving you again! ~ Gotham Cigars
Rosemarie
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
Great products and reasonable prices.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you're pleased with our great products and reasonable prices! Providing our customers with quality products at affordable prices is something we truly value. Your kind w...
Read full response »Dobbie
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
It's fine
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're glad to hear that your experience with us was satisfactory! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts and hope to make your next experience even better. Thank you for you...
Read full response »Gas man
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
is there any way i can reorder withot going through all the bullshit. i order about ever 3 to 4 weeks. can you set up a reorder account for me
- Overall Rating: 4
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
Bob’s review
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
Easy to order
- Overall Rating: 9
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: 9
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear that placing your order was quick and easy! We always strive to make shopping with Gotham Cigars as simple and convenient as possible. We truly appreciate your support and loo...
Read full response »Mike
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
Very good experience
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you had a very good experience with us! It truly means a lot to us that you took the time to share your satisfaction. We're grateful for your support and look forward to...
Read full response »Popo
Site Experience FeedbackNov 16, 2026
I didn't find anything that was bad. Ordering was simple and took less time than doing this survey.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear that your ordering experience was quick, simple, and hassle-free! We especially appreciate your sense of humor about the survey taking longer than placing your order! Your kin...
Read full response »DeeO
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
was looking for an old store I used to buy pipe tobacco from but found they closed down. found gotham via google.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 9
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're sorry to hear that your previous pipe tobacco store closed, but we're so glad your Google search led you to Gotham Cigars! We know how important it is to find a reliable place to shop for you...
Read full response »Jon
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
Website is quick and easy, the ideal of i. And out i lile
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you love how quick and easy our website is to use! We understand that sometimes you just want to find what you need, place your order, and be on your way without any has...
Read full response »Louthestewd
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
I always ordering but you guy are the best... Everything is easy to put your hands on..Easy selection, so much items to choose from...Job well done...
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! Your kind words truly made our day! We're so grateful for your continued loyalty and thrilled to hear that you consider Gotham Cigars the best! It's wonderful to know that you enjoy our wide select...
Read full response »Online Shopper
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
I found my last order and reordered from that, but it is supposed to be auto send and I will call to find out why they haven't sent our October shipment.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Snowman
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
Website worked well. No issues
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that our website worked smoothly and you had no issues during your visit! Making your shopping experience easy and hassle-free is always our goal, and it's wonderful to know ...
Read full response »br
Site Experience FeedbackNov 15, 2026
Great
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you had a great experience with us! Your kind words mean so much to us, and we're grateful you took a moment to share them. Thank you for your support, and we look forwa...
Read full response »Yogi
Site Experience FeedbackNov 14, 2026
Overall, I had a good experience on the Gotham Cigars website. I enjoyed browsing the selection, and the product descriptions helped me get a feel for the different cigars. The only thing I would change is how easy it is to compare sizes. I found myself going back and forth between product pages to check the length and ring gauge. Having those details right on the listings would make it easier to narrow down my choices. I’d shop here again.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear that you enjoyed browsing our cigar selection and found the product descriptions helpful! We also appreciate your thoughtful suggestion about displaying cigar lengths and ring...
Read full response »Eric
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 14, 2026
Much fresher than the ones at the store, when you can find them. Very good price.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 10
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: 10
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you're enjoying the freshness and great prices of our cigars! We know how frustrating it can be when your favorites are hard to find at local stores, so it's wonderful t...
Read full response »Raj
Post-Delivery FeedbackNov 14, 2026
Gotham has great deals but they don’t ship to my home state due to state laws, I had to get creative so I could get what I wanted at a great price.
- Overall Rating: 10
- Would Shop Here Again: 10
- Likelihood To Recommend: 8
- On Time Delivery: 10
- Customer Support: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so happy to hear that you appreciate the great deals we offer! We understand how disappointing it can be when shipping restrictions prevent us from delivering directly to your home state. Unf...
Read full response »Joe
Site Experience FeedbackNov 14, 2026
Good
- Overall Rating: N/A
- Would Shop Here Again: N/A
- Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
From Gotham Cigars
Hi, thank you for your feedback! We're so glad to hear that you had a good experience with us! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your thoughts. Your support means a lot to us, and we look forward to serving you agai...
Read full response »
