Skip to main content

GameFly - Game Rental Customer Reviews

GameFly - Game Rental holds a 9.3/10 overall rating and 812 verified post-delivery reviews on Bizrate.

GameFly - Game Rental logo
Certified
Most Current Certification:
Nov 7, 2026
At GameFly, we are on a mission: to put video games where they belong, in the hands of the gamers who love 'em.

GameFly - Game Rental Rating

Customer Certified
Certified

Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

Circle of Excellence
Circle of Excellence - GameFly - Game Rental

2006 Winner Platinum Circle of Excellence

1 years

Trust & Authority

No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!

Learn more about reviews
Post-Delivery Feedback - 812 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.3out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.2out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.2out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

88%83%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

6%10%
Negative rating icon

Negative

6%7%

On-Time Delivery

Satisfaction with order arrival relative to expected order receipt date

9.1 out of 10

Order Tracking

Satisfaction with the ability to track the order

9 out of 10

Product Met Expectations

Correct product was delivered, is of the expected quality, and works as described/depicted

9.4 out of 10

Customer Support

Satisfaction with assisted or self-service help

9 out of 10

Product Availability

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.2 out of 10

Returns Process

Satisfaction with the returns process

8.6 out of 10

Site Experience Feedback - 2,652 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.2out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

79%79%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

15%15%
Negative rating icon

Negative

6%7%

Ease of Finding What You Are Looking For

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.1 out of 10

Design of Site

Satisfaction with the look and design of the site

9 out of 10

Satisfaction With Checkout

Satisfaction with the checkout process

9.3 out of 10

Product Selection

Satisfaction with the breadth of products available on the site

8.9 out of 10

Clarity of Product Information

How clear and understandable was the product information

9.1 out of 10

Charges Stated Clearly

Total purchase amount (including shipping, handling and discounts) displayed before order submission

9.2 out of 10

Prices Relative to Other Online Retailers

Comparison of prices relative to other websites selling similar products

8.9 out of 10

Shipping Charges

Satisfaction with shipping charges

8.6 out of 10

Variety of Shipping Options

Desired shipping options were available

8.6 out of 10

Recent Reviews for GameFly - Game Rental

Showing 1 - 50 of 3,464

  • trik68

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    There needs to be an availability tag when looking through the catalog of games. You only get to see this once you place it into the que.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Meat man Steve

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 6, 2026

    Good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 6
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Ili

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Zain

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Found really good deals. Been waiting for price drops and gamefly consistently has the best price.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Games come on time everytime. Always in good condition.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Lui

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 5, 2026

    Great, it’s an easy site to navigate and the checkout process was smooth.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Josh

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    Just decided to keep the game i rented

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Angel

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    I watched the count down with funko fusion came out and always want the game

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • MccayFam

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    It was seamless. I logged in, went to my q and chose to keep one of the games I already had out.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • TODD OLIVER

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    I thought the checkout experience was quick, easy, and very easy to use.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • HAPPY MOM

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 4, 2026

    WE GOT THE GAME WITH IN A COUPLE OF DAYS

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Dave P68

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Wanted to check my game for purchase. Saw upgrade was available. Was able to use coupon and discounts. THANKS. Glad I browsed tonight.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Carlitowayjr10

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Gamefly is the best I can have, it can have everyone I like to play much and I have fun playing, I recommend it to everyone.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Scott P

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    The price initially seemed good but after adding in the shipping and handling it worked out to be the same as if I had bought it from another retailer. Pricing is really the only reason why I go to you guys and you also have a lot of physical games which is nice.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • BWolf

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    It's really nice to be able to try out the game before having to buy it outright especially when if you go to sell the game after you beat it it's pennies to the dollar

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Andy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    It arrived on time and in good condition.

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Billy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Hyhd

    • Overall Rating: 5
    • Would Shop Here Again: 6
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 6
    Full ratings for this review »
  • tuxpeng

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 3, 2026

    Website functions well and is clear enough to make finding what I want quick and easy. Have used Gamefly for years and it's nice to see the simple consistency the service has had during that time despite the rental space dwindling.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • PackMan

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    The website was smooth and laid out very well all throughout the process. The prices are great and the coupons and discounts that you get just from having the account helps save a few bucks here and there as well.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • ElPatronPoof

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    Website is very easy to surf through no issues at all

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • AMAYMON

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    Gamefly is a great place to rent and purchase your favorite games, thank you gamefly.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Phat Wang

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    the last game I rented was not able to ship out timely. and i get it due to weather in parts of the country roads/highways get shut down due to safety concerns. It wasnt a bad experience and i have told my buddy to give it a try but its worth it MORE if you just plan on buying the game.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 7
    • Customer Support: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • sabor

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 2, 2026

    everything is fantastic

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • TP

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 1, 2026

    I love Gamefly I just could not keep up with the cost as I try to cut back on my budget

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 2
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • D-Rock

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 1, 2026

    Everything is good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Erick

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 1, 2026

    Good service, just wish more games had availability to rent. Most of my Q is "very low" and that's disappointing, and very limiting in my decision to keep the service regularly if nothing I want is available.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Hatchy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 1, 2026

    All games work great and was satisfied when they came in mail and highly recommend this website for any games you want.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 7
    • Customer Support: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Bob

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    First experience using a reward to make a purchase. Great experience and I will do it again.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Gene2

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    the games are really clean and if you do keep it they seem to send all the stuff that comes with it without giving it away or stealing it.

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 8
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Vertalus

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    Great site

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tboneguy91

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    The game showed up on time and was in much better shape than I expected in an original case.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Brisk

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    Quick and Easy

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Giovanni90

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    very good experience always have the games i want to rent

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    Wish cash app would be accepted

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Zentor

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 31, 2026

    easy purchase

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • LeoWolf

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    Oh well it’s sorta caught in the mid 2010s but it’s efficient enough and I love how well it works honestly.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    Rudolph the rednosed raindeer. Had a very shinny nose. Let it Snow, Jingle bells and silent night.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Speedy delivery

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    it was delivered sooner than what I was expecting very bappy

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • snarklefist

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    everything was easy as usual.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Pyre

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    great price, fast shipping, great service

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • g13at420

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 30, 2026

    Had trouble just buying the pre-order, had to buy a membership to complete it. Then my first checkout would not go through, so I had to do a 2nd attempt.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Disgruntaled

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    The bad thing i would have to say is the lack of physical discs that you have. Often i find (even when the there's a gamelock) i'm waitng for a selection to be filled. this shouldn't be in my opinion considering how long i've been a customer of Gamefly

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Halo2u

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    I'm impressed with how far gamefly has come over the years. Quick return is great!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 8
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    I have experience

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    Used game was more expensive than it should be (but all Switch 2 games are)/

    • Overall Rating: 5
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Jrock

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 29, 2026

    Awesome

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Fishdeodorant

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 28, 2026

    Good. I Like the store. I check it often.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Panda

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 28, 2026

    very eady to use, very ideal to rent before buying ti see if the family like the game instead of wasing money purchase in the store with no return poilcy and teade i with low value.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 28, 2026

    Always good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Shingo

    Site Experience Feedback

    Oct 27, 2026

    Website was easy to navigate and fast.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
GameFly - Game Rental Customer Reviews | Verified Customer Reviews at Bizrate Surveys