Skip to main content

GameFly - Game Rental Customer Reviews

GameFly - Game Rental holds a 9.3/10 overall rating and 789 verified post-delivery reviews on Bizrate.

GameFly - Game Rental logo
Certified
Most Current Certification:
Nov 18, 2026
At GameFly, we are on a mission: to put video games where they belong, in the hands of the gamers who love 'em.

GameFly - Game Rental Rating

Customer Certified
Certified

Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

Circle of Excellence
Circle of Excellence - GameFly - Game Rental

2006 Winner Platinum Circle of Excellence

1 years

Trust & Authority

No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!

Learn more about reviews
Post-Delivery Feedback - 789 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.3out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.2out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.2out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

88%87%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

6%10%
Negative rating icon

Negative

6%4%

On-Time Delivery

Satisfaction with order arrival relative to expected order receipt date

9.1 out of 10

Order Tracking

Satisfaction with the ability to track the order

9 out of 10

Product Met Expectations

Correct product was delivered, is of the expected quality, and works as described/depicted

9.4 out of 10

Customer Support

Satisfaction with assisted or self-service help

9 out of 10

Product Availability

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.2 out of 10

Returns Process

Satisfaction with the returns process

8.5 out of 10

Site Experience Feedback - 2,581 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.2out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

8.9out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9out of 10

Overall
Rating
Past 3
Months
Past
Month
Positive rating icon

Positive

79%77%
Neutral rating icon

Neutral

15%19%
Negative rating icon

Negative

6%4%

Ease of Finding What You Are Looking For

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9 out of 10

Design of Site

Satisfaction with the look and design of the site

9 out of 10

Satisfaction With Checkout

Satisfaction with the checkout process

9.3 out of 10

Product Selection

Satisfaction with the breadth of products available on the site

8.8 out of 10

Clarity of Product Information

How clear and understandable was the product information

9.1 out of 10

Charges Stated Clearly

Total purchase amount (including shipping, handling and discounts) displayed before order submission

9.2 out of 10

Prices Relative to Other Online Retailers

Comparison of prices relative to other websites selling similar products

8.9 out of 10

Shipping Charges

Satisfaction with shipping charges

8.6 out of 10

Variety of Shipping Options

Desired shipping options were available

8.6 out of 10

Recent Reviews for GameFly - Game Rental

Showing 1 - 50 of 3,370

  • JC

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    The rental experience is great, but sometimes the purchasing of games can be clunky and confusing. Games may not be available to buy even if I already have them at home rented.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Tiffy

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    Great Experience with Gamefly , Price wasn't very clear . But Overall Awesome!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 5
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 5
    Full ratings for this review »
  • mike

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    it was fine. found what I was looking for bought it and moved on.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Pablo

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    It was good and fast

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Fro

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • First checkout

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    Solid experience liked applying more than one coupon

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 4
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Nintendo Dad

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    hoping the game is real and looks good. will know more when it arrivss

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 3
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Lynk1976

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 17, 2026

    site works great. easy to use and navigate

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • J

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    The experience was good

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • g13at420

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    I love Gamefly and would recommend to any gamer I know. No bad aspect ro be found. Yes of course I would recommend and have.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • BeachLobsta

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Easy to buy and easy to navigate!

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • T. Chapman

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Gamefly is convenient however it seems that some of the options that are available appear to be limited. However, the website has always worked for me without glitches. This transaction was smooth and I did not have any issues. Loved the discounts that are available on my account; helps to reduce the price of my purchases.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Alley b

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 16, 2026

    Easy navigation

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • finch

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 15, 2026

    found a game i was interested in on sale for a good price.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Njdevil

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 15, 2026

    I bought the game with $10 in coupons. Every few months I get $5 coupons. When I get 2 of them I usually buy the cheapest game in my queue. Game was delivered quickly and im very happy with the purchase

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Chrispy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 15, 2026

    I needed something to carry my console in and the maker of the brand didn't have as much availability or this specified item. The expense went up of the systems but this carrying case is well worth the purchase. This is where i go for online video game merchandise

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    N/a

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • LoganW

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    I bought this game used and was able to use my 25% off coupon. The game and case are in excellent condition, and the game works perfectly. I am very pleased.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Adrian

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    Purchase was easy and shipping was prompt. Tracking number was provided and item arrived on time

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    they werre late with the delivery and refused to offer help

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    • On Time Delivery: 1
    • Customer Support: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Giovanni90

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    amazing service allowing to get games

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Sam

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 14, 2026

    I like it but wish my rental fee discounted the game more since I have rented it for 3 months.

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Anthony

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Great.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 7
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 6
    Full ratings for this review »
  • George

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    I tell my friends constantly, just how great the process is not to mention the prices. Never had an availability issue and the keep it prices and process and smooth as well.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Jrock_oneeye

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 13, 2026

    Awesome store and I recommend it to everyone

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    • On Time Delivery: 10
    • Customer Support: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Roth

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    Coupons should be stackable.

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Fully

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    None

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Coty

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    i'm really enjoying gamefly!

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Bttrfngrbandit

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    The good: Easy to navigate and find what you're looking for. The bad: Since the app updated, I'm not sure if dark mode has been removed or in a different location in the app but it's much easier on my eyes than this bright, default background.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Rye

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    Appreciate that you still distribute physical media for reasonable prices

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    Spending 100$ shipping should be free that’s all I like to add.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Shelbi

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    I liked this website it was easy rent games to play so I didn't have spend 70 dollars on a game and it was quick to ship. Getting discount to keep brand new games is nice to paying a fraction of the price for a game thats been out not even a year yet

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Wavy Jones

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    I think it went pretty smoothly. They gave me the option to keep the game, it was pretth affordable, so I decided that I should just pay to keep it instead of holding my queue hostage while I work my way through the various routes of this visual novel. This way I get to enjoy the game and they'll send the next one on my list. The checkout process was pretty seemless too and I was able to get checked out in under 2 minutes as a result.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 6
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Alienboyc

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 12, 2026

    The feature to just buy the game you've been playing is pretty solid. Probably like 80% of the reason to use it

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Cnyle

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    cnylelaca@yahoo.com

    • Overall Rating: N/A
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Ken

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 11, 2026

    easy

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Wolfeh

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    since i already had the game was a simple and quick purchase. very convienant.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • N/a

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    n/a

    • Overall Rating: 1
    • Would Shop Here Again: 1
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 1
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Guy

    Post-Delivery Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    I just wish I had a used game coupon to use when I bought the game.

    • Overall Rating: 9
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    • On Time Delivery: 9
    • Customer Support: N/A
    Full ratings for this review »
  • D.A.H.

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 10, 2026

    my interaction was great

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Lee

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    Cool service really the only place you can rent games anymore

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 7
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Hans

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    i like the platform and that there's an app makes it more convenient. I do not like how long it takes to get a new game when you send your current game back.

    • Overall Rating: 8
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I love it.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Paul

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    All good

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Gaktar

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 9, 2026

    I love being able to try a game before I purchase it and apply my coupons to the prices.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • J Ro

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    Excellent

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 10
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Inexactcorpse

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    I like that the fees aren’t ridiculous and there always a great stock available which makes GameFly a viable option.

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: N/A
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 10
    Full ratings for this review »
  • sincity

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    never

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 9
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • David P

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    Was a nice discount. Will use again

    • Overall Rating: 7
    • Would Shop Here Again: 3
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 9
    Full ratings for this review »
  • Online Shopper

    Site Experience Feedback

    Nov 8, 2026

    It was quick and easy

    • Overall Rating: 10
    • Would Shop Here Again: 8
    • Likelihood To Recommend: 8
    Full ratings for this review »
GameFly - Game Rental Customer Reviews | Verified Customer Reviews at Bizrate Surveys