Schneider Saddlery Reviews - 1,441 Post-Delivery Reviews - 8.9/10

Most Current Certification:

Jun 19, 2026

At Schneiders, horses define who we are. We understand the bond between horse and rider, and we've built our company around helping the horse community care for our equine partners. You'll find the best-fitting horse blankets and fly gear, durable stable supplies, English and Western horse tack, and horse care essentials to keep your horse happy and healthy. Your satisfaction is 100% guaranteed and backed by the best customer service in the equestrian community. Family owned since 1948.

Schneider Saddlery Rating

Customer Certified

Customer Certified stores provide satisfactory service at a minimum and are committed to proactively collecting customer feedback on their service levels through the Bizrate Buyer Survey.

Circle of Excellence

2025 Winner Circle of Excellence

13 years

Trust & Authority

No More Shopping Fails: Learn more about how our Verified Reviews are legit and empower you to shop with confidence!

Learn more about reviews

Post-Delivery Feedback - 1,441 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

8.9out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.4out of 10

Overall Rating	Past 3 Months	Past Month
Positive	80%	76%
Neutral	10%	10%
Negative	10%	15%

On-Time Delivery

Satisfaction with order arrival relative to expected order receipt date

9 out of 10

Order Tracking

Satisfaction with the ability to track the order

9 out of 10

Product Met Expectations

Correct product was delivered, is of the expected quality, and works as described/depicted

9.1 out of 10

Customer Support

Satisfaction with assisted or self-service help

8.8 out of 10

Product Availability

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.2 out of 10

Returns Process

Satisfaction with the returns process

8.7 out of 10

Site Experience Feedback - 7,070 Reviews

Overall Satisfaction:

9.4out of 10

Would Shop Here Again:

9.5out of 10

Likelihood To Recommend:

9.5out of 10

Overall Rating	Past 3 Months	Past Month
Positive	85%	82%
Neutral	13%	15%
Negative	3%	3%

Ease of Finding What You Are Looking For

How easily were you able to find the product you were looking for

9.3 out of 10

Design of Site

Satisfaction with the look and design of the site

9.2 out of 10

Satisfaction With Checkout

Satisfaction with the checkout process

9.3 out of 10

Product Selection

Satisfaction with the breadth of products available on the site

9.3 out of 10

Clarity of Product Information

How clear and understandable was the product information

9.4 out of 10

Charges Stated Clearly

Total purchase amount (including shipping, handling and discounts) displayed before order submission

9.2 out of 10

Prices Relative to Other Online Retailers

Comparison of prices relative to other websites selling similar products

8.9 out of 10

Shipping Charges

Satisfaction with shipping charges

8.2 out of 10

Variety of Shipping Options

Desired shipping options were available

8.9 out of 10

Recent Reviews for Schneider Saddlery

Showing 451 - 500 of 8,511

Steve
Post-Delivery Feedback
May 2, 2026
I needed a couple of halters. Order was easy to submit. Vewry satisfied.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
iris
Post-Delivery Feedback
May 1, 2026
Schneiders horse blanket wash is good product. I wish it included the ability to deodorize the blankets at the same time of washing without having to buy a separate product. Other wise, the blankets come out clean.
Overall Rating: 9
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
cheryl
Site Experience Feedback
May 1, 2026
fine
Overall Rating: 9
Would Shop Here Again: 9
Likelihood To Recommend: 8
Full ratings for this review »
Kippy
Site Experience Feedback
May 1, 2026
Easy to find the halter that I like and I have ordered in the past
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Georgia Girl
Site Experience Feedback
May 1, 2026
I was not expecting the pop up of "additional freight charges will be invoices. This occurred AFTER I had placed the order and entered my credit card information. Good companies should clearly display this information BEFORE the purchase is complete.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Ulie Bug
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 30, 2026
Familiar with schneider site, found it smooth
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 9
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Dee Dee
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 30, 2026
The hay bags I purchased are great! Able to hold 3+ hay flakes. Easy access for my elder mares.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Order came quickly...but
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 30, 2026
The horse blanket was fine but I reported that the separate storage bag had a cut mark on it. I do not want to return ...I will tape it.
Overall Rating: 3
Would Shop Here Again: 2
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 1
Full ratings for this review »
Sue
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 29, 2026
It was annoying that you did not automatically connect me to my account via your email informing me of my rewards points balance. It is also a very simple Technical update to show the free shipping qualification on the order form. Since you do not, now I have to monitor this order.
Overall Rating: 8
Would Shop Here Again: 9
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Diana Cortes
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 29, 2026
The web- site was very easy
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Lowfry
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 29, 2026
Highly recommend! Website is easy to navigate. Products are priced decently. Shipping is fast. Customer service is wonderful and quick to respond. When making a return, it is very easy. Products are good quality. Great company! Have ordered from them many times and will continue to do so in the future.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 29, 2026
Love the website, fast delivery and love all the options for product.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Buzz
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 28, 2026
Love Schneiders. Good selection and prices and always shipped promptly
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Saddle Up with RJS
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 28, 2026
Easy to use the search engine to find items
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Kathy
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 28, 2026
Great service when needed!
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Nancy
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 28, 2026
Customer service was great. But would have been better if they were available on the weekend.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Janet S
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 28, 2026
I ordered online and decided to add to my order the next day. I called and they added it. No problem at all. Great service. Took less than 2 minutes.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 7
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 27, 2026
Really great return policy. Even though the items didn't fit, the return was very easy.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 8
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Phil K
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 27, 2026
all interactions went without any hitches, very easy to use.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Dave
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 27, 2026
Easy finding the product I was looking for, the pricing was good and it was in stock. I would order again with the ease of everything and the selection to pick from.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 27, 2026
I was shorted a saddle rack
Overall Rating: 6
Would Shop Here Again: 6
Likelihood To Recommend: 6
On Time Delivery: 6
Customer Support: 5
Full ratings for this review »
Sue
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 25, 2026
I like that Schneider’s has great sales at the times of year that I’m looking for the item, like blankets and sheets. The selection is generally good.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Trish
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 23, 2026
Very easy to use, excellent quality of products, helpful reviews
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Bailey
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 23, 2026
It was quick and easy! My package arrived much sooner than expected! It was easy to put together and I absolutely love having a saddle rack!
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Peggy
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 22, 2026
Good
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
2horsemom
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 22, 2026
Schneider’s is easy to order from. Most items are in stock and when they are not, it’s easy to see and you get notified if you want to be. Most items I’ve ordered have been delivered prior to the stated delivery date.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 22, 2026
Website easy to use, prices are good and product availability is good.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Heather
Site Experience Feedback
Apr 21, 2026
Search engine not great BUT the blanket I bought was superb so I’m buying another today. I like the filter for blanket selection
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 21, 2026
The shipping box was crushed on one end and there was no packing paper in the box, also no invoice. The bottle of fly spray leaked in the bag it was in so the other bottles got all fly spray. FedEx not my favorite.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
Good product
Overall Rating: 8
Would Shop Here Again: 8
Likelihood To Recommend: 8
On Time Delivery: 4
Customer Support: 8
Full ratings for this review »
KK
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
I really like these fly sheets. Fits nice and its durable.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Deb
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
Just love the product. Very affordable and quality made.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
GM
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
Everything arrived on time and is good quality
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
HorseMom79
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
Better to find what you want and order from Amazon instead. The reason I always order from Amazon instead is they have free shipping and free returns. If I didn’t have e to pay for returns I 100% would be returning this fly sheet. It fits smaller than a 72, which he wears in every other sheet/blanket. Also, the vitamin E didn’t come with a pump - given the cost for it, that’s absurd. So I ordered one from your site and it leaks worse than any generic plunger. I’ve ordered off Amazon ever. It’s wasting half of the vitamin E that I paid for. It leaks for a full minute after I do a pump. I at least thought your pumps would be better quality considering they’re coming from a horse shop. I am just going to keep the fly sheet because I do I did even though it’s small, and I had to start the vitamin E right away so I didn’t have a choice because I threw away my last pump because it was so old. I’ve already ordered new pumps off Amazon, so it’s not an issue. But I will not be ordering from your shop again clearly the quality is not what you would expect from a horse shop. First time and last time. And the fact that you have to have a large order to get free, shipping is absolutely ridiculous.
Overall Rating: 7
Would Shop Here Again: 4
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Suzy
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 20, 2026
I just started back riding horses. Needed to get a few essentials. I found exactly what I needed on the Schneider Saddlery’s website and was able to purchase them at a reasonable cost. If I continue riding and need more apparel or equipment I will definitely be visiting Schneider Saddlery again.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Minsue
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 19, 2026
Schneiders has a huge selection of quality products at good prices. Their sales are exceptional and we like to take advantage of them to get products we know we will be needing.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
PJ
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 19, 2026
This was a reorder of the blanket wash and odor eliminator products. I love these products and use them every year to wash my horse blankets. There is no residue and this product doesn't remove the water proofing in my turnout blankets. I also use these products to clean my dogs' beds. Highly recommend.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 18, 2026
Fly masks are very well made.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Nancy
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 18, 2026
Quality product and delivered in a timely manner.
Overall Rating: N/A
Would Shop Here Again: N/A
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: N/A
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Sloan
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 18, 2026
Good products easy to find
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Blaire
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 17, 2026
I love the quickness of SS Tack; they are quick about shipping, and if the product is back-ordered, they are great about letting you know. The products they have are of great quality and last long.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Rhoda
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 16, 2026
I ordered an Instahot Pro with cart and cover. I received the unit and cart. The cover came days later. I did call about the cover not coming with the order and the representative was so kind into looking to see what happened. It did come finally,so all is well.
Overall Rating: 8
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
islandhorse
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 16, 2026
great blanket for the hot SC sun! Embroidered and very quickly delivered. I love our Schneiders blankets! They are very durable and the straps are well designed.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Online Shopper
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 16, 2026
The fly boots fell off before I got the new sets on all horses; they are different than last sets I got and are too large of opening on foot side.
Overall Rating: 5
Would Shop Here Again: 1
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: N/A
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Louise
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 16, 2026
Order came so fast, easy ordering and reasonable pricing. I have ordered items from this company before and will continue to do so.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Roni Jo
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 14, 2026
I ordered a sheet and it came with a small snag. Customer support was great and replaced the sheet and I had it in 2 days. Would highly recommend
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Ava
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 14, 2026
Much better fly sheet than the previous one I bought from Schneiders! No issues slipping or rubbing with this one, though I did size down so that may have something to do with it!
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 8
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Denise
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 14, 2026
Very nice products.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: N/A
Full ratings for this review »
Bella
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 14, 2026
Ordered customized saddle and bridle bags. The order was completed and delivered ahead of schedule, and I am thrilled with the items.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: 10
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »
Kapri
Post-Delivery Feedback
Apr 13, 2026
My purchase came in good time. But the galloping boots I bought are way smaller than I thought they would be. So they are on there way back.
Overall Rating: 10
Would Shop Here Again: 10
Likelihood To Recommend: N/A
On Time Delivery: 10
Customer Support: 10
Full ratings for this review »