Liz
Post-Delivery FeedbackDec 11, 2025
My dishes arrived with one dinner plate smashed, the handle of a cup broken, and imperfections in four of the dessert plates. I would have sent the whole set back but that would have required repacking it and paying for the return. The packaging was ridiculously tight and I could never have gotten it back into the original box. and I didn't want to pay shipping. So I kept it, and am now waiting for the plate and cup to be replaced. I gave up on the dessert plates. I'm so disappointed in the quality. I'm very sad my old Midnight Sun pattern chips show noticeably requiring replacement. To replace the chipped items would have been prohibitive. I loved those dishes. The new ones are ok. but I can't match serving pieces such as platter and serving bowls. Oh, and two other cups have rough spots. one cup it is near the rim. All told I'm very unhappy and grieving for my old dishes. I guess the old Pfaltzgraff was sold, and the new outfit has "valued engineered' the product to mediocrity, to increase profits. Very sorry that's been the fate of an iconic brand.