Ben
Post-Delivery FeedbackAug 24, 2025
My first experience with Gotham Cigars was straightforward and aside from the short wait for shipping (Amazon is spoiling me 😏), the shipment was complete and undamaged. The products seem to be in good condition thus far. I had ordered some favorites AF DC Presidente and some samplers. I’ve only had time to try out a few and I’ve only had two that were un-smokable. One was just not capable of any kind of draw, no matter what I tried. Another had the wrapper just fall apart after the cap came off. I tried it all, hole punch, pinning five times, V cut, rolling to try to loosen it up and finally just tried cutting the cigar down an inch to see if I could get a draw without feeling like I was trying to draw a vacuum on a Tabasco bottle 🤬
This was offset by the wonderful samples I’ve tried from Macanudo and Villiger 😌
Thanks for your service and selection!
I also enjoyed looking through the accessories!
I will be back and I’ll let my friends know that you were a good experience.