Alicia R.
Post-Delivery FeedbackOct 22, 2026
My most recent experience with GameFly was a bit frustrating at first, but thankfully, everything worked out in the end. I was trying to update my shipping address to receive games at my workplace, but what should have been a simple change turned into a lengthy email exchange with customer support.
GameFly told me my address was too long for their shipping system because they only allow 32 characters and don't offer a second address line. Since I work at a university, I needed to include specific building, floor, and office information to ensure my deliveries would reach me. I tried explaining this several times, but customer support kept suggesting that I shorten my address or contact USPS. At one point, they even assumed I lived in a dorm, which made me feel like they weren't really reading my explanations.
On the positive side, their support team was polite and responded relatively quickly. However, their email responses felt generic and didn't offer any practical solutions. I was also disappointed that my membership was put on hold over an address formatting issue.
Fortunately, I eventually contacted GameFly by phone, and the issue was resolved. It was a relief to finally speak with someone who could help me sort everything out. I just wish that level of assistance had been available through email from the beginning.
Overall, I still think GameFly offers a great concept, especially for people who enjoy renting physical games without having to purchase them. I would recommend the service, but with some reservations about their customer support and shipping system. My biggest takeaway is that if you run into an issue, calling them might be much more effective than going back and forth over email. I'm glad everything was resolved, but the whole process could have been much smoother.